A parade of money managers who converted mutual funds into exchange-traded funds in a bid to ride rampant demand for the newer, easier-to-trade structures are discovering it may not be so simple to tap the ETF boom.
More than one-third of converted funds have posted net outflows since they made the switch, according to data compiled by Bloomberg, while 61% have attracted less than $10 million each. In fact, only quant giant Dimensional Fund Advisors’s funds have seen significant positive net flows since converting. Even JPMorgan Asset Management, whose overall ETF business is booming, saw net outflows for its converted funds.
Q4 2022 hedge fund letters, conferences and more
The underwhelming results put a damper on the accelerating mutual fund-to-ETF conversion trend as issuers try to recapture the attention of investors who have been spurning old-school mutual funds at a record clip and pouring money into tax-friendly ETFs.
“Just because you convert doesn’t mean the flows are going to come in,” said Eric Balchunas, senior ETF analyst at Bloomberg Intelligence. “The dog has to want the food in the bowl. If it’s a bad strategy, it won’t sell no matter what bowl it’s in.”
By converting an existing fund, issuers hope to bring an established track record and assets to the ETF market, giving each strategy a head start. They also aim to forestall investors from exiting the mutual fund.
That approach so far appears to be working for Dimensional. Its seven converted funds drew in a total $9 billion last year, helping the firm’s full lineup of 30 ETFs pull in roughly $25 billion total.
But the overall net inflows from newly converted funds demonstrates that success isn’t a given. Funds of all the other issuers combined saw a net outflow of $700 million last year.
Given the market volatility, the outflows across 32 ETFs with $9.9 billion in assets isn’t a disaster. Investors pulled $1 trillion from mutual funds last year, while adding $628 billion to ETFs, according to data compiled by Bloomberg Intelligence.
Due to this migration, issuers will keep the conversions coming. Bloomberg Intelligence estimates that about $1 trillion worth of mutual fund assets could be converted into ETFs over the next 10 years.
“You have to do something,” said Balchunas. “The ETF market is simply where the fish are biting. It’s the preferred vehicle of the vast majority of advisors and even investors at large.”
Read the full article here by Emily Graffeo, Advisor Perspectives.
